On Who Can Run the Company Tomorrow

By Dave Sutton, Managing Partner, Blue Rhino Capital

On Sunday, November 8, Nvidia's board opened an independent investigation of its founder and CEO, Jensen Huang, "in light of recent reporting that founder and CEO Jensen Huang has been the target of a foreign intelligence effort." The statement ended: "The Board has confidence in Jensen and his leadership team."

That same day, in an email published by CNBC, Huang apologized for personal conduct, pledged to cooperate, and told colleagues, the board and shareholders: "you deserve better from me." A company statement to CNBC said he was "committed to continuing to lead NVIDIA as CEO without interruption."

On Tuesday, November 10, the independent directors hired former acting U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of New York Joon H. Kim and Wachtell, Lipton, Rosen & Katz. On Thursday, November 12, Nvidia announced that Huang had resigned as president, CEO and director, effective immediately. CFO Colette Kress became interim CEO and remained CFO. Harvey C. Jones was named the first-ever chair, and the board opened an internal and external search for a permanent successor.

I'm not going to guess at the personal facts. A statement of confidence is a claim. The process is the proof.

An apology is a statement. An investigation is a process.

In Built for Trust: How Organizations Build Credibility as a Competitive Advantage, forthcoming from Greenleaf Book Group in 2027, I call Huang's email presence before perfection: saying what you can before every fact is in. "Leaders can respect the investigation without hiding inside it." An apology is still a statement. An investigation is a process, and it has to be visibly able to reach a different answer. Otherwise a board's confidence reads as the conclusion. Tuesday's hire was the first public sign that it might.

In a chapter I call Building Trust at the Speed of Doubt, I write that "doubt moves at the speed of anticipated belief." The useful question is "where confidence could break, how quickly the doubt could travel, and whether the company has built the evidence, authority, and channels to respond before the clock starts." Four days later, the board named an interim CEO, created its first chair, and opened a search.

On Tuesday, November 17, Nvidia reported third-quarter revenue of $115.8 billion, up 103 percent from a year earlier. Interim CEO Colette Kress told investors it was "business as usual" and closed the call with "We've got this." Board chair Harvey C. Jones said the board had "unanimously accepted his resignation and does not intend to reinstate Jensen as CEO." He said the board had retained Heidrick & Struggles to lead the CEO search, and would not take questions "regarding the circumstances of Jensen's resignation and the ongoing investigation." The investigation is still open.

What makes a board's words believable

The Board's Trust Mandate, shown below, asks four questions: Purpose, Proof, Power and Pressure.

Figure 8.1, Board Governance Questions, from Built for Trust: How Organizations Build Credibility as a Competitive Advantage (Greenleaf, 2027). Four questions around the board. Purpose: What are we here to do, and which promises are essential? Proof: What evidence supports those promises? Power: Who decides, and who can challenge? (highlighted) Pressure: What could pull behavior away from the mission?

Power comes first in a CEO crisis: "Who makes the decision, who can challenge the decision, and where can concerns be escalated without fear or delay?" On Thursday, Jones said the board had "full confidence in Colette and the leadership team." That is another claim, and it will be judged by whether the system can make it true.

Kress addressed employees at a company meeting on Wednesday, November 18. According to remarks reviewed by WIRED, she said pay was the most common topic among roughly 700 questions submitted in advance, and the next most common request was for transparency from the board. She told staff that raises and additional equity would arrive in December, months ahead of schedule.

I call the CEO the Chief Coherence Officer. The CEO "owns coherence: the alignment among what the company says, what it rewards, how it decides, what its systems produce, and how leaders behave when the tradeoffs become uncomfortable." Trust cannot be delegated. "If the company came under pressure tomorrow, would stakeholders believe management long enough for reliable evidence to catch up?" That answer holds only if someone can run the company in the morning, and if the board is careful about what it predicts.

A petition is a claim, too

By Wednesday morning, November 18, a "Stand with Jensen" petition calling for Huang's reinstatement had reached nearly 200,000 signatures on the campaign's own counter. More than 10,000 of those names are self-identified as current Nvidia employees; those affiliations have not been independently verified. Elon Musk, Garry Tan, Tobias Lütke and Tim Sweeney are among its backers. Major shareholders Altimeter Capital and Atreides Management had already urged the board to consider all options, including his return. On Tuesday, Huang said he would be "honored to answer these calls and return as CEO" if the board decided it was in the company's interest.

Loyalty like that is earned, and I don't doubt it is sincere. But a petition is a statement of confidence, too. It is the same kind of claim the board made on Sunday, only louder, and neither one is evidence of what the investigation will find.

This is where the fourth question in the Board's Trust Mandate matters. Pressure asks, "Which incentives, deadlines, dependencies, or performance demands could pull behavior away from the mission?" A public campaign, a stock price, comments from Washington and an earnings call, all in one week, are exactly that kind of pressure. If the board reverses course because the campaign got loud, it trades one claim for another. That is Trust Theater. If it finishes the investigation, says how the decision will be made, and then decides, the outcome can be believed whichever way it goes, including a return.

Notice what the petition itself asks for: a fair investigation and more transparency about the departure. Even Huang's supporters are asking for proof, not just a reversal. Last week, Nvidia told CNBC it was selecting a search firm and had not formally engaged any candidates. That was the right kind of process statement. On Tuesday, Jones said the firm had been hired. As Anthony Scaramucci put it on X, "The FBI doesn't take petitions."

Three questions for any board

Most boards will never investigate a founder in public. I would still ask three questions.

Who can run the company tomorrow? If the answer is only the person in the job, confidence in that person is also a single point of failure.

What will you publish on day one? Names, scope, a timeline, and how findings will be shared make the outcome believable.

What will you refuse to predict? Process statements can be kept. Predictions about uninterrupted leadership become debts if the facts move. Sunday's company statement said Huang would continue as CEO without interruption. By Thursday, that sentence was no longer true.

The Trust Maturity Model™ runs from Trust Theater, the claim without a system behind it, to Trust Capability, where the proof exists before anyone asks. A statement of confidence does not create that capability. It only reveals whether you have it.

If your CEO left tomorrow, who would run the company, what would you be prepared to publish, and what would you refuse to predict?


Where does your organization stand? Take the Trust Maturity Quiz. It takes about five minutes.

Dave Sutton

Dave Sutton is a leading authority today on Transformational Marketing– enabling businesses to reach, connect and engage with customers in a way that gives them a reason to care, a reason to buy, a reason to advocate and, most important of all, a reason to stay. He is the founder of TopRight, LLC– a Transformational Marketing firm that helps companies move to the top right quadrant of their competitive frame, and corner the markets where they choose to compete. TopRight’s 3S Playbook model of the right Story, the right Strategy, and the right Systems turns sales transactions into customer experiences that connect and communicate why you do what you do and what difference it makes for your customers. Dave is also the co-author of Enterprise Marketing Management: The New Science of Marketing- the ground-breaking book considered to be the definitive statement of a new business discipline designed to create sustained, profitable, organic growth.

https://www.bluerhinocapital.com
Next
Next

On Trust that Survives the Prospectus